|
Read the Shiur
PARSHA MIKETZ (All rights reserved to Keren Yishai)
Parashat Miketz “Ner Channuka, Pharaoh’s dream, and Peace” Rav M. Elon As in every
year, so too this year we find the parshiyot dealing
with Yosef coinciding with Channuka. Therefore we will
examine Yosef and the course of events surrounding his life, as well as the
Festival of Channuka, and also the deep connection between these two
matters. We will open with the words of
the Rambam that conclude the Laws of Channuka, which conclude Sefer ha’Zemanim (“The Book of Times,”) the third of the fourteen
Volumes that comprise the Yad ha’Chazaka,
(“Strong hand” – “yad” having the numerical value of
fourteen, denoting the fourteen volumes of Maimonides’ monumental work
encompassing all of Jewish Law.) “Should he have before him (the performance
of) Shabbat Candles and Ner Channuka (literally “the
Channuka light”) or (Shabbat) Candles and Kiddush of Shabbat – (the performance
of) Shabbat Candles takes precedence by reason of Sh’lom
Beito, (“Shalom Bayit” –
“Peace of the home,”) for the Divine Name may be erased in order to make peace
between husband and wife.” (Hilchot Channuka 4:12) The Rambam
describes a reality wherein one has sufficient funds to purchase either Shabbat
Candles, or Channuka Candles, (or alternately to purchase Shabbat Candles or
wine for Kiddush,) and the Rambam establishes the Halacha in favor of Shabbat
Candles. Shabbat Candles take precedence
over the other mitzvot for the sake of ‘Shalom Bayit’
– for God’s very name is erased simply in order to bring about peace between husband
and wife. [In the case
of the Sotah, the wife suspected of adulterous
behavior, God’s name is written on parchment which is then immersed in water,
erasing the name. The woman then drinks
the water which reveals whether she is guilty as charged by causing her death,
or alternatively shows her innocence bringing about her immediate fertilization
and pregnancy.] Before we
continue with the words of the Rambam, let us examine the evident question that
arises from the words we have just read.
Would it not seem more appropriate to place the law we have just studied
whereby Shabbat Candles precede Channuka Candle and Kiddush wine in the Laws of
Shabbat? For the Rambam determines that Shabbat
Candles take precedence, for Shalom, Peace, is the most fundamental
concept. Why, then, does the Rambam
record this Halacha here, in the Laws of Channuka? Indeed the Rambam’s concluding words also deserve explanation: “Shalom is (so) significant for the entire
Torah was given in order to bring Shalom – peace – to the world, as the verse
states: ‘Her ways are ways of pleasantness, and all her paths are peace,’ (Mishlei (ibid.) It is
specifically the straightforward nature of the Rambam’s
words that lead to their lack of clarity.
Stating that Shalom is a value which carries great import is stating a
clear and apparent precept, however stating that “the entire Torah was
given in order to bring Shalom to the world” encompasses all of Torah,
including those mitzvot between man and as fellow, as well as those mitzvot
between man and God. It is precisely
here that the lack of clarity arises. It
is quite clear that the Torah - through its mitzvot – causes true peace to
prevail between man and is fellow. However, how do those mitzvot which are
solely between man and God (which the Rambam seems to have included in his statement)
lead to Shalom? Thus we have
two questions which require us to further examine this specific topic, while
simultaneously particularly delving into this concept of “Shalom,” “Peace,”
that the Rambam speaks of. Regarding our
first question, as to the placing of this Halacha together with the Laws of
Channuka, while it seems that the more appropriate location for this Halacha
would be with the Laws of Shabbat, Rav Mordechai Frome answers that the
key to understanding the Rambam’s concluding words in
the Laws of Channuka lies in his opening words to these halachot. The Rambam
states as follows: “In the (era of the) Second Temple when the
Greek Emperors imposed decrees on Yisra’el, and annulled their religion, and did
not allow them to busy themselves with Torah and Mitzvot, and they set their
hands upon their possessions and their daughters, and they entered the Temple,
breaching through at many points, and they defiled the pure (objects,) and they
oppressed them (Yisra’el) greatly, until the God of our Fathers had mercy on
them, and He saved them from their hands, and rescued them, and the Sons of the
Chashmona’im, the High Priests, triumphed over them,
killing them, saving Yisra’el from them.
And they appointed a king from among the priests, and the monarchy
returned to Yisra’el for over two-hundred years until the second destruction
(of the And when Yisra’el triumphed over their enemies, annihilating them, it
was the twenty-fifty of the month of Kislev.
They entered the (Hilchot Channuka, 1:1,2) These are the
only laws in the Rambam, says Rav Frome,
that open with an account of war. Therefore the Ramabm
chose to conclude his laws in this section with the concept of peace and its
deep significance. The appreciation that
Shalom, Peace, is above all can be gleaned from the reality wherein two laws
collide with each other, as we find when Shalom (Shabbat Candles) takes
precedence over the other concerns, (Channuka Candles or Kiddush.) Rav Frome’s answer settles the first question,
however solely in the structural-codification plane of the Rambam’s
work. The full comprehension of the
intrinsic bases of these issues and their internal relationship that binds them
with Channuka still lies before us. We will
attempt to delve into the nature of this Shalom that the Rambam describes in
his closing words to his Laws of Channuka.
We will attempt to show that it is this very Shalom that lies at the
basis of the Miracle of Channuka. Let us
now begin bit by bit. Our sages have
taught us that the nation of “Return, return, the Shulamit,
return, return so that we may behold you. What will you see in the Shulamit? As it were the dance
at Machanayim.” (Shir ha’Shirim 7:1) Why is Yisra’el termed “Shulamit?” Our Sages offer a number of reasons, [Cf. Shir ha’Shirim Rabba, ibid.] all of which are on the concept of Shalom
(shin, lamed, mem) that is contained in the name Shulamit, (shin, vav, lamed, mem, yud, tav.) One of the
answers is based on the verse in Tehillim: “When the earth and all its inhabitants are
dissolved, I establish up the pillars of it.” (Tehillim 95:4) Our Sages
expounded this (in order to explain the name “Shulamit,”
given to Am Yisra’el) as follows: “Rabi Shemu’el bar
Tanchum and Rabi Chanan son
of Rabi Berachya Botzrai
(said) in the name of Rabi Yirmiya: ‘A nation that made Shalom between Me and My
world.’” (Shir ha’Shirim 7:1) We thus
encounter the term ‘Shalom,’ ‘Peace,’ in a context that we unfamiliar
with. We are accustomed to the concept
of peace between ourselves and our Father in heaven, or peace between us and
ourselves, what is the nature of this ‘peace’ that God attains with His world
through Yisra’el as the mediators? We
must clarify this point. The Midrash
continues: “For if it (the nation of (ibid.) Then our Sages
expound the verse from Tehillim that we mentioned: “As Rav Huna said in the name of Rabi Acha:
It states, ‘When the earth and all its inhabitants are dissolved’ – if Yisra’el
had not stood before Me at (ibid.) In other
words, “When the earth and all its inhabitants are dissolved” – the entire
world would have pointlessly floundered and faltered if it were not for Yisra’el’s acceptance of the Torah, meriting to hear that
“I” of “I am the Lord your God,” which was the merit upon which “I establish up
the pillars of it.” It is in this merit
that the world stands firm and strong. As we have
stated, we must clarify the nature of this Shalom, this peace, between God and
His world. In fact, as we will soon see,
this Shalom of the Shulamit is the very Shalom with
which the Rambam concludes his Laws of Channuka, for the concept of Shalom
between God and His world stands at the heart of the miracle of Channuka; for
it is that Shalom that the Greeks desired to violate, and it was that Shalom
that the Chashmona’im restored to its correct place. And in further
elucidation, we will consider the Sages’ exposition to the following verse: “And the earth was without form, (“to’hu,”) and void (“vo’hu”); and
darkness was upon the face of the void, and the spirit of God hovered above the
water.” (Bereshit 1:2) Our Sages expounded
this verse with relation to the four major empires that will arise in history: “Rabi Shim’on ben Lakish solved the verse (with regard) to the exiles (“galuyot,”) – ‘And the earth was
without form’ – this is the exile of ‘And vo’hu’ – the is the exile of the Medes, ‘And they hurried (‘va’yavhilu’) to
bring Haman,’ (Esther ‘And darkness’ – this is the exile of ‘Upon the face of the void’ – this is the exile of the empire of evil
which has no grounds, just as void has no foundations – so too the evil. ‘And the spirit of God hovered’ – this is the spirit of the Messiah.” (Bereshit Rabba 2:4) At a
superficial level the words of our Sages in relation to Yet this is
exactly the point – the battle of Yisra’el against [This is the
basis of the Aristotelian concept of deity who is beyond the knowledge of the
world’s affairs, and in any case does not supervise it. Cf. the beginning of the Kuzari,
First essay, in the words of the philosopher.] Man, and only
man, dominates the world. He creates,
and he acquires wisdom, and he will prostrate himself before the human body at
the various Olympic Games, and he will be the standard by which all achievement
is measured. This world is a dark world,
a world wherein the Divine does not materialize in even the smaller aspects of
life. God is detached, cold and distant. In contra-distinction to this, the Nation of
Israel desires to demonstrate that not only is God associated with His world –
but there is not a single crevice in the world that lacks God’s command and
that does not reveal the Infinite. Let us now
move on to Yosef, and the issues will become even clearer. Yosef passes through three “stations” in This gradual, incremental
structure can be observed in two respects. Firstly, the power and authority
that Yosef acquires in each new location that he finds himself. The second indication of Yosef’s
development is various declarations that he makes at each stage demonstrating
his advance in the world of upwards spiritual growth. As we noted,
his first “station” is in the house of Potiphar. The verses describe his position and his
circumstances as follows: “And God was with Yosef, and he was a
successful man; and he was in the house of his master the Egyptian. And his master saw that God was with him, and
that God granted success to everything he set his hand to. And Yosef found favor in his eyes, and he
served him; and he placed him in command over his house, giving him
responsibility for everything he owned. And
it came to pass from the time that he gave him control over his house, and over
all that he had, that God blessed the Egyptian's house due to Yosef; and God’s
blessing was upon all that he had in the house and in the field. And he left all his affairs in Yosef’s hands, and he did not concern himself with anything
regarding him except for the bread which he ate; and Yosef was well-built and
handsome.” (Bereshit
39:2-6) Thus, firstly,
“God granted success to everything he did,” which is the first stage of
success. Yosef is given charge of Potiphar’s home, Potiphar leaves
his entire estate in Yosef’s hand except for one
sphere which remains outside Yosef’s jurisdiction –
“and he did not concern himself with anything regarding him except for the
bread which he ate.” This “bread” is in
fact a euphemistic term hinting at Potiphar’s own
wife, as Yosef himself will respond to her advances: “And he said: ‘My master does not even know
what is of me in the house…” (ibid. v. 8) And then he
continues: “There is none greater than I in this house,
and he has not kept a single thing from me, save you, being his wife.” (ibid. v. 9) From there
Yosef is taken to prison: “And God was with Yosef, and He showed him
kindness, making him find favor with the chief warden of the prison. And the chief warden of the prison placed all
the inmates incarcerated in the prison under Yosef’s
charge; and Yosef took care of everything that had to be done there. The chief warden of the prison did have to
look after anything that was under his care, for God was with him and God
granted him success in everything he did.” (ibid. v. 21-23) At this point
there are no limits to Yosef’s authority. He becomes the de facto governor of the
prison. The chief warden allows Yosef
free reign in the prison, and for all intents and purposes becomes a mere
bystander, simply observing Yosef’s actions. The expression of Yosef’s
success is also clearer and more apparent.
In the prison we are told: “God granted him success in everything he
did,” a more general expression clearer than the “God granted success to
everything he set his hand to” that is recorded when he was in Potiphar’s house. In
other words, Yosef’s success has increased and
advanced a stage since his sojourn as the head of Potiphar’s
home. We then move
to the third stage. As we recall, Yosef
is brought before Pharaoh who is greatly troubled by his dreams, which are then
solved by Yosef. Then we read of
Pharaoh’s reaction: “And Pharaoh said to his servants, Can we
find one such as this, a man who has God’s spirit inside him?” (ibid. 41:38) Here we
witness a completely separate realm of success.
The spirit of God, Who created everything that exists, is within
Yosef. Yet there is even more: “And
Pharaoh said to Yosef, ‘Since God has shown you all this, there is none with as
much insight and wisdom and you.’” (ibid. v. 39) Pharaoh, who
has no awareness of God, who recognizes no authority greater than himself,
declares aloud: “Since God has shown you all this.” He recognizes the revelation of God that is
beyond him and normal men. And it is
against this background that Yosef receives his unique powers: “You
shall be in charge of my house, and by your word all my people will be ruled;
only by the throne will I outrank you.” (ibid. v. 40) And then out
of concern for his words having been misunderstood, Pharaoh repeats
and re-emphasizes: “And
Pharaoh said to Yosef, ‘See, I have set you over all the (ibid. v. 41-43) And
then, in a demonstration of Yosef’s absolute powers
over the Egyptian Empire, Pharaoh reiterates: “And Pharaoh said to Yosef: ‘I am
Pharaoh. Without your say no man will lift
up his hand or foot in all the (ibid. v. 44) We
can therefore observe Yosef’s three-stage
progression. While with Potiphar, God hands success into his hand, when Yosef is in
prison the expression of his success is more general, “God granted him success
in everything he did.” Finally, in
Pharaoh’s palace we find the ultimate description “a man who has God’s spirit
inside him.” These
three stages reflect the three stages that Yosef himself experiences in his
travels towards voiding himself before God. After
the description of Yosef’s power in Potiphar’s home, the Torah tells us: “…and Yosef was well-built and handsome.” (ibid. 39:6) Rashi
comments immediately: “He would groom his hair, and due
to this God had the bear – Potiphar’s wife – become aroused by
him (allegorically speaking.)” (Rashi ibid.) The development
that then transpires is: “And it came to pass after these
things, that his master's wife cast her eyes upon Joseph; and she said, ‘Lie with
me.’” (ibid. 7) Yosef’s reaction is described as follows: “But he refused, and he said to
his master's wife: ‘Behold, my master does not even know what is
of me in the house, and he has committed all that he has to my hand. There is none greater in this house than I;
nor has he kept back any thing from me but you being his wife; how then can I
do this great wickedness, and sin against God?’” (ibid. v. 8,9) Yosef
justifies his refusal to take up Potiphar’s wife’s
offer with a number of arguments: firstly, he does not want to betray the trust
that his master has placed in him. And
then finally Yosef argues that his assent would cause him to “sin against God.” Despite
the fact that this is a tremendous level of behavior in and of itself, where
one is able to withstand a repeated and continuing seduction – at Yosef’s level, and for one of such immense character, he
should have mentioned the argument that he would “sin to God” well prior to
making mention of his strong desire to refrain from betraying his master’s
trust. In
any event, Potiphar’s wife does not cease her
advances on Yosef: “And it came to pass, that she
spoke to Joseph day by day, and he did not heed her (invitations) to lie with
her or be with her.” (ibid. v. 10) Then
we find a close encounter with temptation (according to an opinion among our
Sages): “One such day, he (Yosef) went into
the house to do his work; and none of the men of the house were there in the
house.” (ibid. v. 11) Yosef
comes close to erring, he comes to the house in order ‘to do his work’ with Potiphar’s wife, so to speak, yet then the truth dawns on
him in all its strength, and Yosef flees from the unfaithful wife who desires
to lead him to be unfaithful to his lofty identity: “And
she caught him by his garment, saying, ‘Lie with me;’ and he left his garment
in her hand, and he fled, going outside.
And it was when she saw that he left his garment in her hand as he had
fled outside…” (ibid. v. 12,13) From
there Yosef ‘s journey takes him to the prison, after Potiphar’s wife falsely charges him with a crime that he
did not commit. There, at his second
station, in the prison, Yosef meets the chief butler and the chief baker who
are terribly troubled. Yosef understands
that their gloomy countenances are as a result of their dreams. Then Yosef tells them: “Do interpretations not belong to
God? Please, tell me.” (Bereshit 40:8) At
the outset Yosef declares that only God holds the solutions to dreams, and then
he requests that they tell him the content of their dreams. And then, after Yosef hears the dream of the
chief butler, deciphering it appropriately, he requests of him as follows: “But remember me with you when it shall
be well with you, and please do kindness for me - mention of me to Pharaoh, and
you will bring me out of this abode; For
I was stolen away from the land of the Hebrews; and here also have I done
nothing to deserve being placed in the dungeon.” (ibid. v.14,15) The
request that Yosef makes of the chief butler, when in fact he was solely to
rely on God, adds two more years to Yosef’s sojourn
in the prison. [As
Rashi comments on that very verse: “Since Yosef depended on him to mention him
(to Pharaoh) therefore it was necessary for him to remain a prisoner for two
years, as the verse states: ‘Happy is the man who places his trust in God, and
does not turn to the proud, (‘r’havim’)’ (Tehillim
40:5) – who does not place his trust in the Egyptians who are termed ‘rahav,’ (proud.)”] The
verse offers the explanation: “And the chief butler did not
remember Yosef, and he forgot him.” (ibid. v. 23) On
our level, we see no wrong in the request for assistance from someone who has just
received our help. However, at the high spiritual level of Yosef ha’Tzaddik, Yosef the Saint, he should not have placed even
one iota of his trust in a human being. Then
we witness Yosef’s third stage, the stage where he
finally completely voids himself before God. Pharaoh
calls Yosef and offers him a unique opportunity: “And Pharaoh said to Yosef: ‘I
have dreamed a dream, and there is no-one who can interpret it; and I have
heard it said of you, that you can hear a dream in order to interpret it.” (ibid. 41:15) Yosef
the prisoner could very easily exploit this fortunate opportunity that has come
his way to accrue political power, or at the very least to ensure his release
from prison. Any other person would have
used the opportunity before Yosef to praise his own abilities – yet not Yosef ha’Tzaddik! “And Yosef answered Pharaoh,
saying, ‘It is not me, (“Bil’adai”) God will answer Pharaoh
favorably.’” (ibid. v. 16) “Bil’adai” – literally “Without me” – answers Yosef, ‘I am
nothing.’ God, and only God, will offer
a favorable solution to Pharaoh’s dreams. [This
level of character is even greater than Yosef’s
response in the prison. Then, he stated
“Do interpretations not belong to God?”
Yosef offered but a small measure of credit to God, and then immediately
afterwards urges the chief butler and baker: “Please, tell me.”] Therefore
we see an incremental structure in the narrative surrounding
Yosef’s ordeals.
We must note this increment also exists in the immediate surrounds
within which Yosef acts. The house of Potiphar is the house of the chief chef. In the prison Yosef meets prisoners of royal
decree, who yield from the highest class of society. Indeed they are incarcerated owing to errant
behavior, yet still they are figures who may yet be released, returning to
positions of authority, as indeed occurs to the chief butler. From the prison Yosef is taken to Pharaoh’s
palace – the power center of all of Thus, as Yosef acquires further levels of lofty
humility – which we in our positions in life yearn to attain even the smallest
quantity of – he too acquires further power and authority. An interesting point that arises from the verses is
the description of the dreams, more specifically Pharaoh’s dreams. As we will recall, after Pharaoh dreams his two dreams the Torah describes Pharaoh’s inner
turmoil as follows: “And it
was in the morning that his spirit was troubled; and he sent and called for all
the magicians of (ibid. 41:8) Pharaoh tells them his “dream,” (in the singular,)
yet they those magicians are unable to perceive the unitary nature of the
reality, and thus they remain confused, unable to “interpret them to
Pharaoh.” They perceive two separate
dreams, and it is for this reason that Pharaoh is not content with their
explanations. And then, when Pharaoh repeats the dreams to Yosef,
once again he uses the singular for when referring to both his dreams. “And
Pharaoh said to Joseph, I have dreamed a dream, and there is no-one who can
interpret it…” (ibid. v. 15) It is then, when Yosef ha’Tzaddik
has completely voided himself before God, declaring “It is not with
me! God will answer Pharaoh favorably,”
that Yosef understands that Pharaoh’s dream is in fact one. “And Joseph said to Pharaoh: ‘Pharaoh’s
dream is one; God has revealed to Pharaoh what He is about to do.” (ibid. v.25) Pharaoh
feels that Yosef’s solution to the dreams is a true
solution. From then onwards matters
develop further and further, and with regards our discussion, Yosef attempts to
liberate Pharaoh from the point of view of Yosef,
who cleaves to God to the point of voiding himself, understands to perceive the
two dreams as one dream with two components. There, in
Pharaoh’s palace, which represents the climax of the temporal world, there, in
the palace of the tyrant who considers himself a god, who tirades against his
servants, there, in this darkest of places – specifically there is where Yosef
represents the ultimate of light, of might.
It is there where Yosef teaches Pharaoh “Bil’adai”
– “It is not me!” Pharaoh thus reacts
with acknowledgement of the supernal God, then realizing that this is a man “who has God’s spirit inside
him.” On the same note,
Ironically,
however, specifically the glorification of the concept of the deity above man
is the greatest mortification and degradation. The Greek “God” is cold and
detached, leaving the world a dark and dreary place. In
contradistinction to this, the God of Israel is infinite, He manifests in every
single detail of reality. This was so
beautifully stated by the first Lubavitcher Rebbe who said: “He who does not see God in every place –
does not see God anywhere.” The Greeks
desired to defile the oil, they did not negate wisdom, yet they desired it
impure and detached from the Heavenly Deity which manifests in the world. It was through
this that the Greeks tore the heavens from the earth, they tore the Shalom
between God and His world, and it is this that places them as the direct
antithesis of Am Yisra’el – the “Shulamit” who
desires to bring about God’s manifestation in His world. As our Sages stated: “He
who makes peace between God and His world.” This is also
the fusion of the Written Torah and the Oral Torah, between the concentrated,
quintessential spirituality hinted at by the Written Torah which is then
revealed by the personalities of the Oral Torah. Channuka is
the festival of the Oral Torah. It is
the first festival enacted by the Rabbinic Sages. Thus it is in Channuka that God’s word is
manifest in the world, now it becomes apparent that wisdom is not and abstract,
intangible concept that hovers above the world, never to appear in the world,
to the contrary! The light which
represents wisdom appears in the world and publicizes the miracle of Channuka. The light
reveals the Shalom between the heavens and the earth. Now we may
understand the Rambam’s specifically concluding the
Laws of Channuka with a law regarding Shalom, and also we may comprehend his
stating that the Torah was given “in order to bring Shalom to the world.” This is the Shalom between eternity and the
finite, between great, exalted concepts that appear and manifest themselves in
this world. This, then, is
the purpose of Sh’leimut – Perfection – to demonstrate
that in every minutia there are traces of the Greatest One, to illustrate that
the worlds are not torn apart from each other.
This is the purpose of Channuka, to publicize the miracle first and
foremost in our own homes, to ourselves, and then to bring it out into the
light of day. Translated by Sholem Hurwitz Copyright Keren Yishai\Rav M. Elon
|
|||||||||||||
Home | Contact Us | Keren Yishai | Rav Mordechai Elon |